Make Playing Cards vs Shutterfly Custom Playing Cards: Which One Should You Choose?
In the world of custom playing cards, 2025 continues to offer creative individuals, hobbyists, and gift-givers more options than ever before. Two of the most well-known platforms—Make Playing Cards (MPC) and Shutterfly—stand out as top choices. However, they cater to very different needs. If you're wondering which service is right for you, this article will compare MPC and Shutterfly from multiple angles including customization, design tools, packaging, pricing, and shipping.
Customization Depth: A Major Differentiator
When it comes to customization, Make Playing Cards clearly leads the race. MPC provides a professional-level platform that allows you to customize nearly every element of your deck. Whether you want to change the card size, choose from various card stocks (like linen, smooth, or plastic), or apply foil or embossing to the box, the possibilities are nearly endless. MPC even supports custom designs on both the front and back of each individual card, making it an excellent choice for designers and game creators.
By contrast, Shutterfly offers a more streamlined experience. Their customization features focus primarily on adding photos and text to the back of each card, while the faces typically remain standard. This limited design flexibility may not suit those looking to produce a full custom deck, but it's perfect for casual users wanting a quick and thoughtful personalized gift.
Design Tools: Professional Flexibility vs User-Friendly Simplicity
The differences in customization extend to the platforms' design tools. MPC supports professional templates, including PSD file uploads, for full-deck design and layout. Its online editor is comprehensive, offering flexibility in how each card is built. This makes it the preferred tool for artists, illustrators, and independent game developers.
On the other hand, Shutterfly's design interface is extremely user-friendly, built for quick photo uploads and drag-and-drop placement. Users can apply preset layouts, add filters, and type in short messages without needing any design experience. It’s an excellent choice for someone creating a personal deck for a friend or family member.
Packaging Options: Premium vs Practical
Another big difference between these two platforms lies in their packaging. Make Playing Cards offers a variety of packaging choices, including standard tuck boxes, luxury magnetic boxes, and custom-printed boxes with glossy, matte, or foil finishes. This level of detail makes MPC especially attractive for those producing high-end card products for resale or collectors.
Shutterfly, however, provides more basic packaging. Most decks come in a clear plastic case or a minimalistic gift box. While this is more than enough for casual or personal use, it might feel underwhelming if you're aiming for a more polished or commercial presentation.
Pricing and Bulk Orders: Scaling vs Gifting
Pricing is another area where your goals will determine which platform is best. Shutterfly's playing cards are generally priced higher per unit, especially when purchased in small quantities. However, they frequently offer discount codes and seasonal sales, making them an attractive option for personal or holiday gifts.
In contrast, MPC offers bulk discounts, making it far more cost-effective for creators ordering in larger quantities. Whether you're fulfilling a Kickstarter campaign, selling on Etsy, or producing educational card decks, MPC’s scalable pricing is more suitable for business or long-term creative projects.
Turnaround Time and Shipping: Speed vs Reach
If you’re based in the U.S. and need your custom playing cards fast, Shutterfly is hard to beat. Most orders are fulfilled quickly and delivered within a week. Their logistics network is optimized for domestic delivery, making them a go-to option for time-sensitive gifts.
Meanwhile, MPC ships globally and provides multiple shipping options including standard and express. While production can take longer—especially for complex, full-deck customizations—MPC’s reach and flexibility make it more versatile for international customers and varied project needs.
Which One Is Right for You?
If you are an artist, educator, or game designer who needs total control over your card design and packaging, Make Playing Cards is the obvious choice. It offers everything from individual card customization to luxury finishes and scalable production options.
However, if your priority is to create a personalized gift deck using family photos, pet portraits, or fun memories, Shutterfly provides a faster, easier, and more intuitive experience. It’s ideal for birthday surprises, holiday gifts, or wedding favors that need to look charming without requiring much design work.
Final Thoughts: Make Playing Cards vs Shutterfly in 2025
Ultimately, the decision between Make Playing Cards and Shutterfly depends on your purpose. For those seeking professional-grade customization and bulk production, MPC is built to deliver. For casual users wanting a fast, beautiful, and heartfelt gift deck, Shutterfly offers simplicity and speed. Both are excellent platforms in 2025 — the right one just depends on what you want to create.
